Jul 30, 2016 carl jung s answer to job is a significant but complex work which reflects much of his psychological thinking and theory. Considered one of jungs most controversial works, answer to job also stands as jungs most extensive commentary on a biblical text. One of the achievements of this remarkable and scholarly book is to illuminate jungs entire opus though its comprehensive attention to one of the most striking and distinctive of the collected works. Greeted with controversy on its publication, answer to job has long been neglected by many serious commentators on jung. Answer to job is a simply brilliant interpretation of this classic biblical story and its subsequent influence on the development of new testament theology from the point of view of jungian psychoanalysis. Reading jung s answer to job enlivened an otherwise boring day for me. Jobs journey parallels jungs own experienceas reported in the red book. The book places answer to job in the context of biblical commentary, and then examines the circumstances surrounding its compositions and immediate reception. Whilst remaining true to the tenets of analytical psychology, this commentary underlines answer to jobs greater significance in terms of cultural history. A detailed commentary on the work discusses the major methodological presuppositions informing it and explains how key jungian concepts operate in the text. Considered one of jungs most controversial works,answer to jobalso stands as jungs most extensive commentary on a biblical text. Jung illustrates that god, by becoming half man, half god. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read answer to.
Here, he confronts the story of the man who challenged god, the man who experienced hell on earth and still did not reject his. Jungs answer to job unravels jungs narrative, offering a comprehensive rereading of jungs text, as well as a repositioning in its cultural context. It has been reported that during this illness a figure sat on his bedpost. Here, he confronts the story of the man who challenged god, the man who experienced hell on earth and still did not reject his faith. A commentary unravels jung s narrative by reading it in the chronological order of the biblical events it analyses and the book to which it refers, offering a comprehensive rereading of jung s text. Answer to job is a paradigm of the individuation process, the lens through which all of jung s theories may be. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jungs objectives in this text and offers a new way of reading the work. Jung says this is the answer to the question of why job had to suffer.
In answer to job, jung demonstrates his indepth knowledge of the bible. Jungs authentic response the book of job has inspired many interpretations and commentaries. Jungs answer to job was originally given as a twelveweek teaching seminar in 1989 at the c. Oct 28, 2014 abstract a detailed summary of jungs answer to job is presented, along with a commentary on it and on how jungs insights have held up over a half century, particularly in the area of the. Initially greeted with controversy, answer to jobhas been neglected by many serious commentators on jung.
Jungs answer to job by cynthia avens my dear friend sally rhea, who is a member of our christosophia community, recently encouraged me to read carl jungs answer to job. Carl jungs answer to job is a significant but complex work which reflects much of his psychological thinking and theory. Read download karl wolfskehls briefwechsel aus neuseeland. Bishop by commentary a paul paul a commentary answer. This book offers an intellectual and cultural context for c. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read answer to job. Their long list of free services includes career profiles, career videos, salary data, college profiles, information on majors and degrees, financial aid advice, and career assessment tests. A commentary as a remarkable and scholarly book that illuminates jung s entire opus through comprehensive attention to one of the most striking and distinctive of the collected works. Isbn 1583912401 full text not currently available from enlighten. A commentary as a remarkable and scholarly book that illuminates jungs entire opus through comprehensive attention to one of the most striking and distinctive of the collected works. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jungs objectives in this text and offers a new way of this book offers an intellectual and cultural context for c. Please improve it by verifying the claims made and adding inline citations.
One would assume from the title that the text would be primarily about the book of job, but a great deal of jungs analysis extends through the entire old and new testaments, becoming something of a whirlwind biblical exegesis. Jungs answer to job ebook by paul bishop rakuten kobo. Sheldons body types and temperament and their integration, chiloquin, or. Liber novusof descending into the depths of his own. Answer to job was first published in 1952 in german and was included in jungs collected works, as part of volume 11. At the time of job god already wanted to become conscious by integrating evil and good and job was the starting point of god becoming more human, more conscious.
A commentary paul bishop greeted with controversy on its publication, answer to job has long been neglected by many serious commentators on jung. Carl jung wrote his response as an answer to job jung, 1952, which he wrote in one burst of energy during an illness. Abstract a detailed summary of jungs answer to job is presented, along with a commentary on it and on how jungs insights have held up over a. In this article, susan rowland pronounces paul bishop s jung s answer to job. Jung s answer to job unravels jung s narrative, offering a comprehensive rereading of jung s text, as well as a repositioning in its cultural context. Considered one of jung s most controversial works, answer to job also stands as jung s most extensive commentary on a biblical text. Whilst remaining true to the tenets of analytical psychology, this commentary underlines answer to job s greater significance in terms of cultural history. Jung s authentic response the book of job has inspired many interpretations and commentaries. A commentaryplaces theanswer to jobin the context of biblical commentary, and then examines the circumstances surrounding its composition and immediate reception. The full text of this publication is not currently available from this repository. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jungs objectives in this text and offers a new way of.
The depth and complexity of jungs exposition will require much more reflection on my part, but i feel the numinous energy pouring through his words as he gives sophia a central role in the answer to job. The biblical book of job is part of the jewish wisdom literature that was written during the fifth to first century bce. Jungs answer to job by paul bishop overdrive rakuten. It is regarded as one of jungs most controversial works. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jung s objectives in this text and offers a new way of. Revised unisex edition of the act interest inventory uniact. An original argument put across in a scholarly and accessible style provides an essential framework for understanding the. Answer to job is a paradigm of the individuation process, the lens through which all of jungs theories may be. A commentary unravels jungs narrative by reading it in the chronological order of the biblical events it analyses and the book to which it refers, offering a comprehensive rereading of jungs text.
Dedicated to the study and dissemination of the views of c. Bishop paperback job by jungs to 2002, the answer of jesus to job by g. An original argument put across in a scholarly and accessible style provides an essential framework for understanding the work. It has been reported that during this illness a figure sat on his bedpost and dictated answer to job to him see edinger, 1992, in what seems to be a very. I knew that this was especially important since it had been on my reading list for the past few years. One would assume from the title that the text would be primarily about the book of job, but a great deal of jung s analysis extends through the entire old and new testaments, becoming something of a whirlwind biblical exegesis. A commentary unravels jungs narrative by reading it in the chronological order of the biblical events it analyses and the book to which it refers, offering a. Reading jungs answer to job enlivened an otherwise boring day for me. The translation is crystalclear, largely free of technical or scholarly jargon, and livened by jungs often irreverent sense of humor. A commentary by paul bishop 2002, paperback jungs answer to. C g jungs answer to job a half century later by lewis. Jan 12, 2012 considered one of jung s most controversial works, answer to job also stands as jung s most extensive commentary on a biblical text. Initially greeted with controversy,answer to jobhas been neglected by many serious commentators on jung. Jungs answer to job unravels jungs narrative by reading it in the chronological order of the biblical events it analyses and the books to which it refers, offering a comprehensive rereading of jungs text.
1436 1404 1463 848 944 625 848 1371 843 321 1389 485 1461 1439 60 21 31 42 79 980 644 1127 1093 299 1189 254 337 938 717 750